Monday, August 19, 2013

Rhino horns, tiger teeth and why Asians eat wildlife to extinction

(This post is also in Vietnamese:  Sừng tê giác, răng cọp và tại sao người Châu Á ăn động vật hoang dã đến tuyệt chủng.)

My weeks-old youngest brother’s fever was not responding to conventional medicine. So my mother decided to use what she believed had worked for her four older children. She ground the tiger tooth in a small stone mortar, added a couple of teaspoons of water, then spoon-fed my brother the milky-white liquid.

Tiger teeth and claws sold as amulets and charms to ward off evil spirits
Source: Wild Asia
He died the next day. In a fit of rage, my father took the tiger tooth and threw it into the river a few meters from our back door.

The tiger tooth was a family heirloom, given to my parents by my relatively rich saw mill-owning maternal grandparents in the Mekong Delta town of Rạch Giá as a wedding present. I wore this very tiger tooth around my neck the first two years of my life. It was believed to not only possess medicinal properties, but also the power to ward off ‘evil spirits,’ from which I needed protection as the first-born son.

According to legend, tigers once roamed the forested swamps of the Mekong Delta region and the tooth came from one of those tigers whose spirits now lorded over the underworld. In reality, that ‘tiger’ tooth could have come from a water buffalo, a wild boar, or even a big dog. No one ever asked why or how those tigers were killed, or if they ever existed.

When we moved to a rural village outside Rạch Giá, we discovered a few pairs of migrating white egrets had built nests in a cluster of melaleuca trees (cây tràm) on our land. Everyday my brother and I couldn't wait to check on the nests. We would snatch the eggs as soon as they were laid. We even managed to shoot down a few birds with a slingshot. After a few years we noticed the egrets no longer came back, but didn’t understand why.

Egrets in Tràm Chim National Park, Vietnam Mekong Delta
Source: Wikipedia
We were poor farmers whose diets consisted mostly of vegetables and fish. We raised chickens and pigs, but they were investments, our savings. The bird eggs and the occasional birds, snakes and turtles, even field rats, were a real treat. When we caught fish, we caught and ate everything, big and small. During the flooding season, the most-prized fish were the baby ones: no bones. The most sought-after baby fish were the snakehead.

Baby snakehead fish -- these are raised for fish farms

To make a meal consisting of baby snakeheads, our family would essentially wipe out four or five broods of future snakeheads, the salmon of the Mekong Delta.

Adult snakeheads -- salmon of the Mekong Delta
Source: Bạn Nhà Nông/Farmer's Friend
We also ate many things for novelty’s sake, for their rarity. Importantly, we didn’t understand how NOT taking the egrets’ eggs or catching the baby snakeheads would be beneficial to us. We thought if we didn’t, someone else would. 

The concept of wildlife protection or nature conservation was not part of the culture. The terms were not even common words.

After nearly 11 years in the U.S., I went back to Vietnam for the first time in 1992 to find my family much better off, no longer subsisting off the land. Not long after my arrival, my father put word out among the vendors at the local wet market that he was looking for exotic fare, i.e. turtles, snakes, birds and prized big fish.

He was quite disappointed when I told him all I wanted was steamed water spinach and cá rô kho tộ (anabas or climbing gourami cooked in a clay pot) for dinner. I wanted to taste the simplest meals that I remembered growing up with. My family didn’t quite understand why a man coming back from a rich country would want to eat nothing but peasant fare.

Cá rô kho tộ -- anabas in clay pot: One of the humblest dishes of
Vietnamese cuisines that defines our agrarian roots
Source: Món Ngon Cuối Tuần/Delicious Dishes for the Weekend
They eventually gave up trying to understand me and I on explaining to them that comfort foods were not necessarily expensive or exotic.

Wherever I went on that first visit, everybody wanted to feed me the ‘best’ food, which invariably included wild-caught snakes, turtles, and birds, among others. The notion that wildlife is worth more in the wild than on the plate was not easily understood because many did not see themselves directly, or even indirectly, responsible for the catching or killing of such wildlife. They simply saw themselves as consumers, rationalizing that if they hadn’t purchased the snakes, birds or turtles, others would.

I reminisced with my brother about our childhood and when I explained to him my theory of why those birds didn’t come back to our melaleuca trees, he had a hard time believing it, but I could sense his feeling of guilt. I felt bad for telling him what we, as kids, may have unwittingly done.

Many of my relatives today, including those of the younger generation, relish the opportunity to lavish themselves with potions, elixirs and wild game that once only the rich could afford. They do have an inkling that the potions and elixirs may not possess anything magical, but believing it wouldn't hurt to try them anyway. However, they won't feel nostalgic, or be willing to break the law for exotic animals if and when they’re no longer sold in the market. For them, it has everything to do with the novelty, with a break from the everyday’s Vietnamese three-course meal now that they can afford it. No more no less.

Vietnamese working man's lunch-- cơm bình dân -- soup, stew (salty)
and stir-fried vegetable dishes.
It may take time for conservation education to take hold, to become part of the cultural mindset, and even longer for existing laws to be enforced without being corrupted. Sadly, time already ran out on Vietnam's last Javan rhino and elephant recently and many other species endemic to Vietnam and neighboring Southeast Asian countries are now on endangered list.

The insatiable appetite of Vietnam's newly-rich for the exotic has not only put their natural heritage at risk, but also endangered animals a continent away in Africa. A shocking 1004 South African rhinos were killed in 2013 for their horns, most of which are believed to have been smuggled into Vietnam where a set of horns from a single rhino can fetch up to $1 million.
Business Insider: The Price Of A Single Rhino Horn Now Rivals Gold
Just imagine: on the average, two rhinos are now killed each day because of a rumor that their horns, which are made of keratin just like your and my finger and toe nails, had cured cancer.


(Special thanks to
 Chris Galvin Nguyen for going through my writing with a scalpel like a heart surgeon.)

10 comments:

  1. Hi Sonny, Thanks for sharing this.

    I really think that more than anything, it comes down to education - about consumption, conservation, health, and general awareness on endangered species and the web of life, and that people are a part of that web. And it's also about finding sustainable livelihoods for poor people so they don't have to turn to poaching, and going after the more "mafia type" poaching organizations.

    Your last paragraph really highlights what a tragic situation this is.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Suzanne,

      Thank you very much for reading my blog and leaving your comment. Agreed with all of your points. And corruption makes things worse. Seems rather discouraging. I hope conservation groups come up with new ideas & strategies that will arrest the situation quickly.

      Sonny Le

      Delete
  2. An excellent & thought-provoking piece - we'd be very keen to chat to you about reducing demand for wildlife goods in Viet Nam. Please contact me: richard.thomas@traffic.org

    ReplyDelete
  3. A moving read with personal insight into a culture that I am intrigued by and much drawn to - I appreciate your sharing. As you know, just back from Vietnam, and as somebody involved with issues Rhino and Wildlife related, I was expecting to have my heart wrenched by the rats, snakes, rhino horn and sea creatures I would see on offer as delicacies. True - it was difficult given that I spend much time trying to 'save the world'. But also one of the reasons I selected to visit Vietnam was to learn and better understand. And I think I do. Actually I can't wait to return ...
    Truth is I find myself debating the 'honesty' of a traditional (yet no longer sustainable) lifestyle vs. the environmental atrocities of large (American, Asian, European) corporations guilty of over-fishing, oil pollution, exploitation of mineral resources, artificial fertilizing, trademarking of staple foods etc much worse. So as much as we all need educating and to do all that we can as individuals, what you describe is done with no malice.
    Sonny, if there is a place to involve myself, either here or with the end user. I am available and would appreciate the direction as to how best to do so. Much appreciate the contact.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you, Dawn, for reading & sharing my blog, as well as your compliments & honesty. It's tough to read about the worsening poaching & trafficking situation, especially with the rhinos and pangolins. I do feel a sense of guilt by association.

    I believe you understand the situation/perspective quite well. Yes, education is needed. It has to be understood that this way of life is no longer sustainable, like bush meat consumption in Africa & elsewhere. Demonizing ill-informed consumers doesn't help. Pointing out the 'cultural' differences isn't all that helpful either.

    While the consuming countries being pressured to step up enforcement of existing laws & prosecution, I believe campaigners need to ramp up their messaging, directly target less-informed consumers outside big cities (Hanoi, HCM City, Shanghai, Beijing, Bangkok, etc).

    I've been involved in large public awareness campaigns where I've learned there're ways to get to the masses without talking down at them or singling them out.

    Like you, I'm also ready to help, hoping to get involved in crafting messages & PR strategies, which is my background.

    It's rather urgent & that's why I wrote the above. I hope we can meet & work with each other some time soon. Again, thank you, Dawn.

    Regards,

    Sonny Le

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nice write up my friend. Now translate it into Vietnamese so I can pass along to my relatives who still live in VN.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Interesting article, and I hope some good comes from the networks you're helping to create. Thank you

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow. I'm so floored by this writing and by what I just learned from you. I'm not a scientist/academic and I've never been to Vietnam. (Unfortunately, due to circumstances I've never really come to terms with, my father was there.)
    But I do care deeply about habitat preservation and enjoy learning about cultures other than my own.
    Thank you so much for restoring my faith that idly surfing the net can lead to such magnificent discovery.
    Thanks also to Mike the Mad Biologist for linking me here.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for reading my blog. I've also thanked Mike the Mad Biologist. Yes, the Internet is one huge library for info junkies, without having to know how the Dewey Decimal System works.

      Delete
  8. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete